Overview

Express Checkout

Increasing conversion through modern checkout pages

As an e-commerce platform, SamCart aimed to empower sellers and enhance the shopping experience for their customers. After years of success with our sales pages, we wanted to release a more modern, mobile-first checkout experiences to compete with other checkout providers in this fast-growing and crowded space.

Over 6 months I researched, designed, tested, and iterated on 3 new and distinct checkout experiences. In this case study I am sharing the mobile-optimized checkout page that significantly increased conversions for sellers on our platform, which we call Express Checkout.

Background

Turning the "moment of inspiration" into a purchase

Sellers on our platform employ a number of different strategies to sell to customers - sales funnels, email campaigns, lead pages, ads, trials and promotions, etc. Regardless of their strategy, eventually customers would have their “moment of inspiration” in which they decide to purchase and locate the checkout form to provide their payment and personal information and transact.

Previously, sellers created long pages with targeted sales copy to inform the customer of their product offerings, build trust, and possibly offer upsells and cross-sells to increase the Average Order Value (AOV) of the sale. In the years SamCart grew its business, these sales pages went from cutting-edge to dated, and we needed to modernize our offerings to match both seller and customer expectations in a rapidly evolving market.

Goals

Our goals were to:

Modernize our UX and infrastructure

Trends in checkout changed since SamCart launched its sales pages. My team was tasked with improving page load speeds and addressing common pain points in our checkout, all while improving the look and feel of this experience.

Enhance our native features to deliver more value

Sellers trust SamCart to help them sell more and convert more because of homegrown tools such as order bumps (cross-sells) and payment options (commonly used as payment plans). These would need to be adapted and seamlessly integrated into new checkout experiences to maintain user loyalty.

Discovery

Understanding our niche in a crowded market

With Shopify and Stripe setting standards in payments and e-commerce, their checkouts were among the gold standard I compared our solutions to.

Shopify

Shopify is a leader in online marketplace focused on selling physical goods and provides flexible templates and checkout flows for its customers.

Stripe

Stripe offers a lightning-fast payment solution and provides simple checkout pages to its customers.

Kajabi, Thinkific, etc.

On a feature level, we are competing with other platforms in the digital products space and thus wanted to focus on delivering value specifically to digital creators with features such as upsells and cross-sells, seamless integrations, and affiliate marketing.

Turning to users for guiding design principles

In addition to titrating the competitive landscape for ideas, my product manager and I dug through past feedback from our sellers, from support tickets to interviews and feedback surveys. Major themes that were repeatedly raised included:

Speed

Sellers stressed that reducing the number of steps to checkout was crucial in increasing conversions. Cutting friction wherever possible was one of my top priorities, and the engineering team was focused organizing our infrastructure to reduce page load time.

Customization

The popularity of SamCart pages was attributed in part to our numerous templates and the flexibility our editor gave sellers to customize their pages to express their brand identity. I wanted to move toward more optimized layouts like Stripe and Shopify while maintaining flexibility for sellers to adapt the checkout to their brand.

Value

Increasing AOV was top of mind to sellers, and our powerful features to upsell and cross-sell to customers were very successful. These features were a must-have to adapt in the new checkout experiences and they presented a unique challenge to accommodate all on a single page.

Design Process

Moving through a constant iteration-feedback cycle

I had all the building blocks ready for a checkout experience; the challenge was to organize, configure, and style them in a way that met our goals.

I dove right in to prototyping and testing with users, focusing on A/B tests to tease out preferences between multiple checkout variations.

Putting the "cart" in SamCart

To reduce vertical space on mobile and make the checkout seem "shorter," I put many features behind dropdown elements, such as the order summary in an expandable panel that resembled Stripe's mobile "cart" feature. However, this was controversial because our sellers focus on single product orders with options to add products through upsells and cross-sells.

A/B test with internal Subject Matter Experts (SMEs)

I ran an initial A/B study with team members our sales and support team to get their feedback as they represented aggregated perspectives based on their knowledge of user behaviors and pain points. These sessions had the secondary effect of building trust and generated excitement for the Product team's work.

"Wait, what am I buying?"

Because customers would likely be dropped into Express Checkout from ads or other sales pages, it was crucial to confirm the product being purchased with the customer. For that reason, the cart was dropped in favor of a clear order summary featuring the product.

A/B test with sellers

Many of our sellers cater to demographics that are not "digital natives" and therefore require more context on the web and attention to solid accessibility practices. In an era where I see text sizes getting smaller and niche iconography replacing accurate descriptors, their feedback was a great reminder to design for all and not rely on trendy patterns.

Finding the Goldilocks page length

Simply displaying all of our features with clear labeling was not going to work, especially with speed to transaction being a top priority for sellers. This was especially challenging as I was incorporating subscription pricing. To preserve the clarity of subscription terms, all of my designs incorporated these cases to ensure that subscription products would be as neat and understandable as one-time payment products.

A/B test with end customers

I ran an unmoderated study with participants who recently purchased digital products online. Showing variations in an A/B test helped tease out actionable feedback and identify friction points, though these types of studies are imperfect at recreating the conditions and mindset of checking out. At best, all participants understood the purpose of the page, what was available to them, and how to complete a purchase.

Adapting the page for an embeddable experience

Our next offering was an embeddable version of the checkout, called Embed checkout. Sellers often come to SamCart with an established online presence, and we wanted to provide sellers the ability to take our checkout form and all of our lucrative features and plop it directly on their existing pages. However, it wasn't as easy as copying Express Checkout and pasting it onto a page.

A/B test with sellers

The challenge of putting all of our features on an embeddable i-frame led me to design a new experience completely separate from the existing Express designs. I put a number of different layouts in front of sellers for feedback — 1-column, 2-column, multi-step, etc. Sellers surprisingly were open to multi-step layouts as they directed customer attention much more handily than a 2-column layout with everything visible. Those seemed overwhelming and disorganized to them to embed on their content-heavy pages.

Revising both experiences for launch

With insights gained from evaluating both experiences, I updated the designs for both and converged on a more unifying look and feel.

Launch!

Solution

Addressing speed by making 1-click checkout immediately accessible

Since speed consistently ranked as a top concern for sellers, it was important for me to make 1-click checkout options prominent for customers. Options such as digital wallets (Apple Pay and Google Pay) and Link by Stripe are available for users and a majority of customers will see the digital wallets above the fold on mobile devices.

Allowing customization with bold graphics and prominent branded elements

The feature that consistently stood out across my studies was the bold cover image. In addition to the logo and color of page elements, the cover image made a clear brand statement that excited sellers for SamCart's new features and made them stand out against more standardized checkouts like Stripe's and Shopify's.

Delivering value by highlighting cross-sells and upsells

Our native SamCart features were revamped with a modern look and optimized for mobile-first customers. Adding one order bump (our cross-sell feature) to the checkout page on average increases AOV by 31%, therefore it was imperative to highlight these on the checkout experiences.

Outcomes

Outcomes

We launched the Express Checkout feature along with the Embed Checkout feature on July 25, 2023. Prior to launch I gathered positive feedback on the designs and generated excitement for the new features.

Conversion lift

In our beta launch, we saw an average of 6-point increase in conversion. Some sellers saw up to 30-point increases in conversion; this depends on their selling strategies. Overall GMV is up on our platform, suggesting the power of these new tools in positively affecting our sellers' bottom line.

Positive sentiment

On the week of the launch of these new checkout experiences, SamCart broke records for new account signups multiple times. This, in addition to qualitative feedback and support garnered from sellers I've talked to, make me confident that these new features will deliver value for sellers and level up e-commerce on our platform.

Other Projects
1
Improving software development for higher velocity

Developer tools for Fortune 100 client @ UXReactor

2
Increasing engagement through gratuity

Growth feature for SaaS e-commerce platform @ Indiegogo